LoanRating.co.za
Warning: High volume of customer complaints regarding this lender.
Old Mutual

Old Mutual Reviews

94 customer reviews, 1.7/5 average rating

View loan conditions →

4.8/10

Our Score

Rating Breakdown

1.7
★★★★★

94 reviews

✓ Verified

5 ★
14 (15%)
4 ★
2 (2%)
3 ★
2 (2%)
2 ★
2 (2%)
1 ★
74 (79%)

🛡️ Our Honest Take

Old Mutual Finance offers some of the most substantial personal loan amounts available to South African consumers, from R2,000 up to R250,000, with repayment terms stretching from 3 months to 72 months. The fixed interest rate structure is a meaningful differentiator: because your rate is locked at the time of approval and capped at 28% per annum, your monthly instalment does not change when the South African Reserve Bank adjusts the repo rate. This makes budgeting straightforward, particularly over longer terms where variable-rate products can become unpredictable.

The full cost of borrowing includes several components beyond the interest rate. The monthly service fee is R60 excluding VAT (R69 including VAT). The once-off initiation fee is R165 plus 10% of the loan amount above R1,000, capped at R1,050 excluding VAT. For loan terms of 12 months and longer, a credit life insurance premium is charged monthly based on the rand value of the loan at application. To make costs tangible: borrowing R5,000 over 3 months results in total interest of R348.16, an initiation fee of R649.75, a monthly admin fee of R69, and a total amount payable of R6,204.91. Old Mutual's online loan calculator lets you estimate your instalment, including credit life and service fees, for your chosen amount and term.

Applying is straightforward in theory. You can apply online, at a branch, via WhatsApp on 0860 933 333 or by phone on 0860 000 866. The online eligibility form promises a response within 24 hours, and approved loans are stated to be paid out within 24 hours of approval, though Old Mutual notes disbursement times may vary. Contract workers with at least 3 months on their current contract may also apply via the eligibility form, which is broader than some competing lenders. The debt consolidation product goes a step further by having Old Mutual settle your listed accounts directly and issue settlement letters, removing the administrative burden from the borrower.

Customer feedback, drawn from an independent review platform covering all Old Mutual products including insurance, banking and investments, paints a concerning picture. Over the past 12 months, Old Mutual holds an average rating of 1.5 out of 5 from more than 2,500 reviews. Recurring complaints include double debit order deductions, deductions continuing after policy cancellation, refunds promised but never paid, and reports of policies opened on PERSAL numbers without the account holder's knowledge. Communication is a persistent weakness: reviewers describe call centre waits of 20 to 45 minutes ending in dropped calls, emails generating only automated replies, and escalation references that produce new reference numbers rather than resolutions. Positive reviews do exist, typically praising named branch consultants who take ownership and resolve issues quickly, confirming that the underlying processes can work when handled well.

We scored Old Mutual 4.8 out of 10, a figure driven primarily by the very low customer satisfaction rating pulling against otherwise competitive loan conditions including the high maximum loan amount, fixed rates and flexible terms. From a regulatory standpoint, Old Mutual Finance is fully compliant with the National Credit Act, holds NCR registration NCRCP35 and FSP licence 25494, and is obligated to perform affordability assessments on every application. Consumers under debt review are not eligible to take on new credit under the NCA.

The overall verdict is that Old Mutual Finance is a legitimate and well-regulated lender with a genuinely competitive product range, especially for borrowers who need large amounts or want to consolidate debt. However, the volume and consistency of service complaints in independent public reviews is significant enough that prospective borrowers should go in with clear expectations, keep records of all interactions, and be prepared to escalate through the National Credit Regulator or the Credit Ombud if issues arise after disbursement.

Compare Other Options

Before you apply with Old Mutual, compare other providers for the same kind of loan.

Latest Reviews (showing 40 of 94)

★☆☆☆☆Nobandla D
2026/10/01

Terrible service

Terrible service, I am not sure if you don't train our staff about the products you sell or they just don't care! Can you explain what is the whole point of the company having branches and yet when you go to one you still have to call your call centre and still no one can assist you? on my profile I opened a tax free savings account for my minor son, no communication from you regarding the account. Then boom deduction on my account for the savings account. I don't know where it is opened nothing. Sent *** no response as usual!!! Call centre doesn't help hey say it's under my son's profile, how does a minor have a profile? When you create one obviously it's going to say he is a minor, I have not visibility of this tax free savings, no communication letter saying this is ***, NOTHING at all. Please close that account and I will look else where to open it with a company that knows what they are doing.

★★★★★Amanda
2026/09/30

The lady was very nice she even emailed me back after not receiving my email as promised

★☆☆☆☆Pieter S
2026/09/30

My life assurance policy matured. I cannot get Old Mutual to pay the matured value. The policy was ceded to Nedbank but the bond was paid up years ago. Now Old Mutual does not recognize the cancellation of cession letter supp**** by Nedbank. Old Mutual wants a security code on the letter, but Nedbank does not now or heard of the security code request before. You pay the Old Mutual premium for 20+ years without failing one month. Now that Old Mutual must pay the maturity amount we as the public must jump through these impossible hoops. Worst financial institution I have ever dealt with.

★★★★★Buhle M
2026/09/30

Tshekgene Moshokoa you are the best there ever was. Your consistency is amazing. Keep it up

★★★★★Randall
2026/09/30

Tshekgene Moshokoa is the best employee at Old mutual. He always goes over and above

★★★★★Melvin N
2026/09/30

Tshekgene Moshokoa is the best! You deserve everything good in life!

★★★★★KatlegoMogotsi Katlego.mogotsi
2026/09/30

Tshekgene Moshokoa has been an true gem and made everything a breeze.

★★★★★Jabu N
2026/09/30

Tshekgene Moshokoa is the best at what he does. He is a hard worker. Thank you for your professionalism

★★★★★Nende N
2026/09/30

Tshekgene Moshokoa has been very helpful recently. Thank you for your consistency and all your hard work. You are the best keep it up.

★☆☆☆☆Tertius Venter-Davies
2026/09/30

I have a duplicate profile with Old Mutual. This is something only they could have caused. But somehow it has become my problem. I have to send certified IDs etc. to have it corrected. They could never have opened a profile in the first instance without my ID. Cannot access anything on my "portfolio" now.

★☆☆☆☆Nelisiwe D
2026/09/30

Old Mutual customer service is non-existent, including their complaint line. Queries and emails aren't attended to, yet they'll continue making debit orders, and when it comes to giving you the service, they are a no-show. Sad that such a big organisation can treat paying customers in such a manner. I cancel the contract in March 2026 and till today, Old Mutual continue to debit my account and I keep on having to reverse the payments. Sent emails for them to fix this matter and was assigned this ***, yet the matter is still unresolved. Follow-up queries are ignored, and all you get is a standard generic email reply acknowledging receipt of your email, and that will be the only response you'll get :-(

★☆☆☆☆donald H
2026/09/30

Once you become a customer, thats it! NO further client service. You can call, ***, complain all you like - you will not get a response nor will your query be solved. Atrocious for such a big, famous financial company.

★☆☆☆☆Chriswinn
2026/09/30

I put in a claim 1 month ago. Still nothing

★☆☆☆☆Nompumelelo K
2026/09/30

Money was wrongly deducted from my persal, they refuse refund.

★☆☆☆☆tinyiko L
2026/09/30

I am at my wits end with these ********** insurance policy taken out and being gas lighted when I need help and my money back.

★☆☆☆☆Precious
2026/09/30

My cash back was due June but until now haven't received it and nothing is being said

★☆☆☆☆sifiso M
2026/09/29

If your company or you have a retirement saving/ pension fund with old mutual take your money and run away. My mom currently has a medical retirement from my company. A lady by the name Mathabo Manamela who is a *********** working for Old Mutual decided to take the money and not not pay out the claim. They work with Nedbank staff process the claims to unauthorized banking details without their knowledge. Be careful and want statements and application packs from this company it is run by ******** and be careful of so called Old Mutual financial Planners. Old Mutual Contact Number ***

★☆☆☆☆MILDRED B
2026/09/29

No feedback received for more than a month trying to get policy cancelled and refunded. I have tried to contact escalate to complaints department with no luck. Highly disappointed after 21 years being a loyal client

★☆☆☆☆Melissa
2026/09/29

I contacted old mutual with no assistance they haven't been deducting the funds for my policy I have called in on numerous and nobody seem to be able to reinstate the debit order

★★★★★tumi M
2026/09/29

Funeral Claim logged 10 PM and payment received by 9 AM the following morning. Thank you for speedily and excellent service.

★☆☆☆☆Oratile M
2026/09/29

Very dissatisfied with Old Mutual customer service, very poor ..

★☆☆☆☆Cheryl B
2026/09/29

Horrific experience trying to deal with Old Mutual. I'm acting on behalf of my son, under the powers of a Power of Attorney. 2 of my grandsons require surgery in America which is why my son has had to surrender his policy early. OM is aware of the urgency and the reason. It has been an absolute sh..show. We received an e-mail on 24/8 advising that "the funds have been disinvested......". All attempts by the financial advisor to get an update have been ignored by OM. They don't even have the common decency to reply. They don't put the relevant phone numbers on their e-mails, and their reception staff refuse to give us numbers to speak to someone to get this resolved. Shan-Leigh Smith of the PF Retirals has / hasn't been dealing with this. Pathetic service is an understatement.

★☆☆☆☆Terry T
2026/09/29

I was enquired about a premium holiday. The lady who helped me was not friendly but very arrogant. Bad service

★☆☆☆☆Tyrone F
2026/09/29

Old Mutual debited R5,000 from my bank account and, as of 29 September 2026, still cannot account for where my money is. I raised this on 9 September regarding Flexible Investment contract ***. The R5,000 was debited as a final contribution after cancellation of the recurring contribution, but the investment reflected R0. The money was neither allocated to the investment nor returned to me. Old Mutual issued reference *** and advised a turnaround of 5–10 working days. On 20 September I was then asked for proof of the debit before they would investigate further. It is now 29 September. My R5,000 is still missing. At this stage I do not want another acknowledgement, apology or internal referral. I want Old Mutual to explain exactly where my money is and return it immediately if it was not allocated. It should not take weeks for a major financial institution to establish what happened to money it debited from a client's bank account. R5,000 left my account. It did not appear in my investment. It has not been refunded. Where is my money, Old Mutual?

★☆☆☆☆Phumzile
2026/09/28

I hope this email finds you well, I requested that the debit order goes through TymeBank but it went through Capitec, with all due respect please reverse that payment or just close this policy because customer's wishes are not met. I changed my banking details for a reason.

★★★★☆Hervé
2026/09/28

It was great even though the waiting time was a bit longer to get a consultant

★☆☆☆☆Nosipho
2026/09/28

A deeply disappointing and stressful experience with Old Mutual. I was advised that my funeral claim would be paid within 48 hours, but despite submitting all the required documents, I only received the payout five days later — on the actual day of my brother's funeral. What made it worse was the lack of communication; I was never contacted when there was an issue with the claim and had to repeatedly follow up myself while grieving and trying to arrange his funeral. I pay my premiums every month because I trust that this cover will be there when my family needs it. Unfortunately, this experience has seriously damaged that trust. Customers deserve better communication, transparency and support during such difficult circumstances.

★☆☆☆☆Dipuo
2026/09/28

I have a problem i want to claim to Port when I put my ID say it doesn't match

★☆☆☆☆Mmaborwa Constnce Modiselle cmodiselle
2026/09/28

Old Mutual fail me with a funeral cover i have with them since 2012.We divorced in 2024 and He passed on Oct 2025.According to me they deny the Payment because it was Comprehensive. Old Mutual send my contract to the Address i never give them. Even today i did not receive the contract. So i cancel the policy.

★☆☆☆☆Bathabile
2026/09/28

Old Mutual opened a *** on my behalf without my knowledge

★☆☆☆☆Nelly S
2026/09/28

Active Debit not going through. - escalated at Mamelod Branch with no results

Old Mutual Mamelodi Branch. In July 2026 I visited the branch when I noticed that my debit was not going through. The matter was escalated and promised that in August the debit will go through but it did not and made cash payment. In late August I visted the brach again to let them that the same things has happened. Again promised that it will go in Sept, but the same thing happened and then I received a message that my contract/ debit order has been automatically cancelled. I then paid an amount to reinstate the debit order. I then received that the contract has been reinstated. I expected the debit to to through 25 sept, but it did not. Where do I complain?

★☆☆☆☆edwina D
2026/09/28

Worst service once again

Terrible service once again. App**** for a payment holiday on my policies. Was supposed to receive my first payment in the first week of September and still waiting. When i enquired i was advise that monies was paid on 08 Sept. When i asked the account number it was ***, When i asked the account number it was way different of the one i gave my advisor. Up until today still no money and still no proper feedback. I really thought i could give them a chance again but after this i am done. I will be loosing a lot of money coz i have been with them for years, but your service sucks big time

★☆☆☆☆Mahadi M
2026/09/28

On this particular Policy .Good morning, I have a problem with OldMutual I have been call since next week to check my refund but their phone *** is only ringing after choosing the number you supposed to go, my airtime is even gone cause im calling with my cellphone, they supposed to refund me my money from August 2024 to August 2026, on policy ***, that was made paid up in October 2024.but only aware when I was looking for my tax certificate that it was made paid up, but my money was still going to the same Policy, and the person helped said she did ask but now I need to know when can I expect my refund. Regards

★☆☆☆☆tony.gomes tony.gomes
2026/09/28

Refund not received

Good day Im feeling frustrated cause old mutual doesn't wanna give my money back I did a cancellation and all of a sudden I didn't get my refund I feel I don't like their service and I'm disappointed

★☆☆☆☆Nokuthula B
2026/09/28

Old mutual birch acres with horrible customer service and bad attitude from the service advisors. On behalf of my grandfather who is a pensioner have made a payment request from his savings that turned to be a nightmare we have been advised of the 15 days turnaround time that was understandable from the first day we changed the contact numbers which the advisors did not even bother to changed and continued to sent sms to the old number that has more that 5 years of not working, we then accompanied him after 15 days to check we were told to wait another 3 days , follow up done again we are told that the are documents missing which they failed to tell is on several check. The old man is now worried about his savings that he has with old mutual as they seem not to care at all.

★☆☆☆☆Sipho X
2026/09/28

I am extremely disappointed with the service received from Old Mutual regarding my mothe's pension fund transfer from Alexforbes to Old Mutual. When we attempted to submit her tax return to SARS, we were informed that the Record of Transfer (ROT) was missing from Old Mutual. We contacted Old Mutual to resolve the matter and have sent numerous emails requesting assistance and clarification. Unfortunately, despite all the follow-ups, the issue remains unresolved. Instead of taking ownership of the matter and providing a clear resolution, we have repeatedly been referred from one department to another. This has been extremely frustrating and has resulted in unnecessary delays. What makes the situation worse is that the request is straightforward: we need Old Mutual to confirm the status of the transfer and ensure that the required ROT information has been submitted to SARS so that the tax return can be processed correctly. After numerous emails, we still have no satisfactory resolution or clear indication of when this matter will be resolved. *** or *** Old Mutual needs to take accountability for this matter, investigate it properly, and provide a clear written response and closure. Customers should not have to repeatedly follow up for an issue that should be handled between the relevant departments. Very disappointing service and a frustrating customer experience.

★☆☆☆☆Penny M
2026/09/28

My sister passed away and her consultant put in the funeral claim last Tuesday. The funeral is done, out of pocket. Yes, there was a holiday in between but 24 to 48 hours means exactly that. Why allow people extra stress than worrying about their own survival that now hangs on it? The other family has left it falls on me as her beneficiary to get her storage cleared but all the money I had was all put into the funeral. I am very disappointed, not even talking about her trusts that will probably take way longer. Then her will was drawn up by Old Mutual. Go to any lawyer worth their salt and they'll give you a copy and keep the original safe. As if I dont have enough to worry about already . My sister was a hoarder, and at least expected more from a company everybody has heard of. Not a happy camper when you can't just grieve knowing that things are financially settled.

★☆☆☆☆Zikhona N
2026/09/27

They open *** under my name 2025 November and I've been going there since to ask them to cancel the *** because

★☆☆☆☆David N
2026/09/27

I'm am shocked how was treated but old mutual super fund provident fund they can call me there's lady that I would like to speak about with all respect how bad her service is and to show she just does not care it was just to get us to move from Alex Forbes to old mutual after that her service became shocking call me I'd like to report her

★☆☆☆☆Thulisa T
2026/09/27

I am extremely disappointed and frustrated with Old Mutual and the way my issue has been handled. Old Mutual has been deducting money from my bank account for policies that have already been cancelled. I have personally visited an Old Mutual branch five times since August to resolve this issue and request a refund of the money that has been deducted from my account. What is even more frustrating is that I am still being charged on the 25th and the last day of every month, despite the policies being cancelled and the system apparently showing that the policies are no longer active. Every time I go to the branch, the staff tell me that a refund request has been submitted and that I should wait. However, despite numerous visits and requests, I am still waiting for my money, while the deductions continue. It is extremely disappointing that Old Mutual is quick and efficient when it comes to getting customers to sign up for policies, but when there is a problem that needs to be resolved, there seems to be no urgency whatsoever. I have wasted my time travelling to the branch five times, repeatedly explaining the same problem and following up on a refund that should have been dealt with already. This is horrible customer service and has completely damaged my trust in Old Mutual. I want my money! Not *** promising to sort this out.

Want to see loan conditions?

Check interest rates, requirements and how to apply before making a decision.

View Old Mutual Details →